Outsourcing requires trust—because businesses rely on their external partners to meet obligations and uphold customer expectations. But trust is but one element of this partnership—especially for manufacturers operating in complex, global supply chains. For outsourcing to be successful, decision-makers must have visibility into every aspect of the outsourcing operation to fully extrapolate the value these relationships can deliver and understand where there’s room to improve. And the most effective way to manage outsourced processes is by tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) that offer objective, measurable insights into supplier performance.
What Are Outsourcing KPIs?
Outsourcing KPIs refer to measurable values businesses use to track and evaluate the processes or functions they’ve delegated to external third parties. These metrics assess whether or not their outsourcing partners are meeting contractually defined standards for quality, cost efficiency, and operational performance over time.
While KPIs that measure performance of internal teams and processes highlight the workings within an organization, outsourcing KPIs focus on external partners by tracking such metrics as error rates, cost reduction percentage, and schedule adherence. Establishing these KPIs early, such as during the contract phase, ensures alignment, builds accountability, and gives companies the ability to spot and address problematic issues before they escalate to the point where they affect customers.
Key Takeaways
- Outsourcing KPIs measure vendor performance against quality, cost, and operational benchmarks.
- Businesses typically track these KPIs through regular reporting cycles, supported by software platforms with automated reporting capabilities.
- Effective outsourcing management tracks multiple KPIs that reflect business impact across operations, employee workflows, and customer experience.
- Tracking KPIs consistently throughout the partnership lifecycle helps businesses spot difficulties early so they can take corrective action, which ultimately strengthens vendor relationships and controls costs.
Outsourcing KPIs Explained
Maintaining an effective outsourcing operation requires a disciplined approach to data collection and analysis. According to Deloitte’s “2024 Global Outsourcing” survey, a “lack of benefit realization tracking and reporting” was the top drawback cited by more than 500 global business and technology leaders. Without clear performance metrics, it’s nearly impossible to determine if an outsourcing partnership is delivering on its promise.
To remedy this, leaders should choose a focused set of baseline KPIs before any agreement is signed. These metrics should be realistic, measurable, and tied to the specific targets written into the service level agreement (SLA), which typically also defines regular reporting cadences—weekly, monthly, or quarterly, for example—to support transparent reviews, identify trends, and address issues before they escalate. Successful outsourcing relationships track both tactical metrics (such as cost per unit or lead times) and strategic KPIs that reflect longer-term business concerns, such as customer satisfaction or complaint rates.
Most outsourcing KPIs fall into two categories, depending on the stakeholder they serve:
- Company-focused KPIs (cost reduction percentage, ROI, and so on) reflect the financial and operational benefits of outsourcing.
- Customer-focused KPIs (such as net promoter score, complaint rate) monitor how outsourcing affects the end-user experience.
Some organizations also track internal KPIs to assess how outsourcing affects employee productivity and satisfaction, but these metrics tend to be more situational and not part of standard vendor performance monitoring.
10 Crucial KPIs for Tracking Outsourced Projects
To manage outsourced projects effectively, businesses need KPIs that align with their overall objectives. For instance, are you looking to reduce lead times and production costs? Or is it your priority to minimize defects and customer complaints to help stand out in a crowded market?
Though cost-related metrics often take the spotlight, quality and delivery measurements are just as important—especially in manufacturing, where delays and defects can ripple through an entire supply chain. Most companies benefit from tracking a balanced set of metrics that reflect cost efficiency, operational reliability, and customer impact. The 10 KPIs below provide a practical framework for assessing the value of your external partnerships:
-
Cost Per Unit
Cost per unit measures the average expense of producing one item or delivering one service. Businesses use this KPI to compare outsourced production costs against historical in-house production costs, alternative vendor partner rates, or industry benchmarks.
The formula is:
Cost per unit = Total production cost / Number of units produced
This per-unit metric helps monitor cost efficiency as production scales. Unexpected increases may signal operational inefficiencies, increased waste, or rising material prices. Cost per unit is also useful as a pricing tool. For example, a clothing retailer that outsources manufacturing overseas might see lower labor and materials costs, which would reduce its cost per unit. This enables the company to maintain its profit margins—or even lower its retail prices—without sacrificing profitability, despite rises in other costs, such as shipping or tariffs.
-
Cost Reduction Percentage
Cost reduction percentage quantifies the financial savings gained by outsourcing, compared with the cost of performing the same function in-house. It helps determine if outsourcing is delivering the expected financial benefits—a top priority for many businesses. In fact, “cost savings” was cited as the primary motivation for outsourcing in ISG’s “Market Lens BPO” survey of 368 decision-makers from G2000 companies.
The formula is:
Cost reduction percentage = [(In-house cost – Outsourced cost) / In-house cost] × 100
“Cost” should include all relevant expenses, including labor, materials, and allocated overhead. Companies should establish target cost reduction percentages before signing outsourcing agreements, then review the actual figure over time to evaluate performance. If results fall short, it may signal a need to renegotiate the contract or consider bringing some operations in-house.
-
Return on Investment
Return on investment (ROI) measures the financial return of an outsourcing initiative relative to its total cost. It helps businesses assess which partnerships are creating the most value, informing future decisions.
The formula is:
ROI = [(Total benefits – Total costs) / Total costs] × 100
When calculating ROI, include both direct cost savings—such as lower material and labor costs—and indirect benefits, such as quality improvements, faster time to market, and less management overhead. Unlike shorter-term cost metrics, ROI reflects performance over longer periods, such as quarterly or annually.
For outsourcing initiatives, many companies set minimum ROI thresholds—say, 20% to 40%—to indicate that an investment will be worthwhile. If a supplier fails to deliver ROI within that range, the business can attempt to renegotiate the contract or terminate the agreement.
-
Time to Complete
Time to complete monitors how long it takes an outsourcing partner to finish a specific task, process, or project from initiation to delivery. This KPI directly impacts operational efficiency, capacity planning, and customer satisfaction, especially in industries with flexible production needs or volatile demand, such as direct-to-consumer or on-demand manufacturing.
The formula is:
Average time to complete = Total time spent on all completed tasks / Number of tasks completed
By comparing actual completion times to estimates, businesses can identify bottlenecks and forecast project timelines more accurately. Tracking this metric helps businesses contrast actual completion times with estimates, identify bottlenecks, and improve forecasting. It can be monitored at a high level or within specific workflows, such as for customer service tickets or individual product lines.
Depending on the complexity of the outsourced work, time to complete may be measured in minutes, hours, days, or weeks. For instance, an electronics manufacturer might measure resolution times for outsourced customer service in minutes or hours, while outsourced component development could span weeks or months. Improving this KPI often requires visibility into vendor operations to uncover the root causes of delays and inefficiencies.
-
Completion Rate
Completion rate measures the percentage of contracted tasks or projects that an outsourcing provider completes within an agreed-upon time frame. It’s a key indicator of partner reliability and capacity that helps businesses evaluate which partners consistently meet delivery commitments.
The formula is:
Completion rate = (Number of completed tasks / Total number of tasks) × 100
Industry standards vary with the complexity of the outsourced work, but declining completion rates may indicate capacity constraints, workflow inefficiencies, or misaligned expectations—any of which can jeopardize the terms of a service level agreement.
For example, a publishing company that outsources printing and bookbinding may monitor this KPI to ensure that enough copies of a new book will be ready for sale by the release date. If completion rates drop below 98%, the publisher can work with its partner to identify the holdup—perhaps unclear instructions or inadequate staffing—and take corrective action to prevent delays.
-
Error Rate
Error rate measures how often mistakes or defects occur in deliverables relative to total production volume. This is often the primary indicator of quality in outsourced work, helping businesses identify issues in vendor processes, training, or quality control systems.
The formula is:
Error rate = (Number of goods with errors or defects / Total units produced or delivered) × 100
Acceptable error rates vary widely, depending on the type of outsourcing, ranging from near-zero tolerance in pharmaceutical manufacturing to more flexible thresholds in some administrative services. Regardless of where a business’s error tolerance falls, SLAs should define clear thresholds and regular audits should verify quality and compliance.
-
Customer Complaint Rate (CCR)
Customer complaint rate calculates the percentage of customer interactions that result in formal complaints or expressions of dissatisfaction. This KPI provides direct feedback into how outsourcing decisions affect the customer’s experience, often bringing issues to the surface that internal metrics, such as sales or return rates, might overlook.
The formula is:
Customer complaint rate = (Number of complaints / Total customer interactions or transactions) × 100
To figure out where problems are coming from, companies typically categorize complaints by type, severity, and root cause. This becomes especially useful when comparing in-house and outsourced operations, as it helps pinpoint whether complaint rates are more frequently tied to one source or another.
For example, an appliance manufacturer with both internal and outsourced service teams might track whether outsourced interactions generate more complaints and callbacks than in-house service calls. If the data shows a significant discrepancy, the company may need to develop more detailed vendor training manuals or reconsider outsourcing customer-facing functions altogether.
-
Net Promoter Score (NPS)
NPS gauges how likely customers are to recommend a company’s products or services to others. It is often used as a proxy for customer loyalty and advocacy. Monitoring this KPI before and after outsourcing can also help businesses evaluate if changes in vendor operations are affecting the customer experience.
There are several steps to calculating NPS:
First, ask customers a single question, such as “On a scale of 0-10, how likely are you to recommend our product/service to others?” or “On a scale of 0-10, how likely are you to recommend our company to a friend or colleague?”
Based on their responses, customers are grouped into three categories:
- Promoters (9-10): Loyal advocates
- Passives (7-8): Satisfied but not enthusiastic
- Detractors (0-6): Unhappy customers who may damage brand reputation
Next, calculate the percentages of promoters and detractors:
Percentage of promoters = (Sum of all 9 and 10 scores / Total respondents) x 100
Percentage of detractors = (Sum of scores from 0 to 6 / Total respondents) x 100Finally, apply this formula:
NPS = Percentage of promoters – Percentage of detractors
This score can range from –100 to +100. Positive scores are generally good, and +50 or higher is considered excellent. However, expectations vary widely by industry—customers may be more likely to recommend entertainment products than sensitive medical devices, for example.
Because of this variation, companies should track NPS trends over time and check them against industry benchmarks, rather than relying solely on a single score. If values drop significantly after outsourcing, it may prompt a closer look at the partnership or even a reconsideration of returning to in-house alternatives.
-
Customer Satisfaction Score (CSAT)
Customer satisfaction score, often abbreviated as CSAT, measures how satisfied customers are with a specific product, service, or interaction. Like NPS, this score is most useful when tracked over time—especially before and after outsourcing—to capture any changes in quality or service from the customer’s perspective.
First, ask customers a question like “How satisfied were you with your recent experience with [product/service]?” Answers are typically rated on a 5-point scale, with 4 or 5 counting as “satisfied.”
Then apply the formula:
CSAT = (Number of satisfied customers / Total number of customers surveyed) × 100
Unlike NPS, CSAT surveys often contain detailed questions aimed at evaluating specific parts of the customer experience, such as delivery speed, technical support, or packaging quality. This makes the KPI particularly valuable for assessing outsourced functions alongside in-house processes.
-
Schedule Adherence
Schedule adherence tracks how consistently an outsourcing partner completes work on or before agreed-upon production or delivery timelines. This KPI increases visibility into production reliability, an especially important aspect of supply chain management for manufacturers with complex production processes or those with time-sensitive commitments.
The formula is:
Schedule adherence = (Number tasks completed on time / Total scheduled number of tasks) × 100
Companies expect high adherence rates from their partners, though exact benchmarks can vary with operational requirements, such as equipment maintenance or labor regulations. Lower rates may signal resource misallocation, poor planning, or process inefficiencies. Though occasional disruptions will inevitably arise due to external events (say, inclement weather or supply shortages), consistent monitoring can reveal patterns, such as delays that occur during particular shifts or production stages. This KPI helps businesses better distinguish between isolated incidents and recurring bottlenecks.
Drive Better Outsourcing Outcomes With NetSuite
Managing complex outsourcing relationships requires extensive transparency and consistent performance monitoring. Businesses that rely on spreadsheets or disconnected systems often face data delays, fragmented reporting, and limited oversight. NetSuite Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system brings all your financial and operational data into one platform, enabling real-time KPI tracking through customizable dashboards. With built-in tools for monitoring essential outsourcing KPIs, such as cost per unit and completion rates, NetSuite helps teams act faster and with greater confidence.
NetSuite for Manufacturing delivers powerful visibility into both outsourced and in-house operations. Features include vendor scorecards, performance alerts, and customizable trend reports, which give teams the insights needed to uphold quality and delivery standards. The system’s supplier portal also facilitates communication and document sharing to strengthen collaboration with partners.
Effective outsourcing goes beyond selecting the right partners—it demands ongoing transparency and performance tracking to ensure that each relationship meets expectations and aligns with business objectives. The most successful strategies begin with a solid combination of operational and strategic KPIs that are clearly defined and built directly into partner agreements from day one. By consistently tracking KPIs, such as cost per unit, cost reduction percentage, customer complaint rate, and error rate, companies can identify opportunities to strengthen vendor relationships, improve quality control, maximize ROI, and keep customers satisfied.
#1 Cloud ERP
for Manufacturing
Outsourcing KPIs FAQs
Why are metrics in outsourcing?
Outsourcing metrics provide quantifiable assessments of external partner performance. This gives businesses an objective way to determine if their partnerships are delivering value in terms of cost, quality, and efficiency. These metrics also help hold partners accountable and lay the groundwork for potential solutions when performance falls short of contractual obligations.
What are four factors to consider before outsourcing?
Before outsourcing, organizations should:
- Set realistic savings expectations, based on current cost structures and operational benchmarks.
- Define quality standards, including acceptable error rates and customer satisfaction thresholds.
- Evaluate capacity needs that partners must accommodate, including seasonal fluctuations and scalability requirements.
- Align outsourcing decisions with long-term strategy to ensure that decisions will support broader business objectives—not just short-term cost reductions.
How do you track outsourcing metrics?
To track outsourcing metrics, first establish pre-outsourcing performance levels to set a baseline for comparison. Then track new performance data as results come in. This can be aided by software or an ERP system with automated analytics tools. Regularly scheduled review meetings with outsourcing partners are essential for collaboratively analyzing KPI trends, addressing performance issues, and identifying opportunities for strategic improvement.
